i'm dating a guy that  i meant 5 weeks ago. But i feel bad because he told me that he loved me and i said it back but not really there yet. then there this guy on my sports team and i really like him and i told him that i liked him and he said that he likes this girl on my team and i asked him does he think we will be more than friends and he said that isnt impossible what should i do

i think u should maybe give me a chance

first guy is your better choice. the second guy is just leaving his options open and guess what. your his other option in case the first girl doen't work out. in other words, if he can't get any tail off the first girl, he for sure has yours to hit because you told him you were willing and open (know what i mean).

do? breathe! then recoup by taking a long walk preferably away from concrete. you'll find your answer there

I very much agree with what you said !! so girl forget the 2nd guy and be with the 1st guy, he sure will make you happy. it is not necessary you have to be in love with him....... you will end up falling in love with him. Those days are gone of Romeo and Juliet !!

First off do not have expectations, this ruin the relationship prior to beginning.